All You Had To Do Was Stay by Laura StarkeyMy rating: 3 of 5 stars
Hannah is a wedding planner, not gifted academically like her twin brother Ed, she has built up a very successful business from scratch. Ed is dating Joe Gibson, a psychotherapist, successful podcaster, author and TV presenter. Joe and his brother Jude were brought up in the same road as Hannah and Ed, in fact when Jude transferred to their secondary school Hannah was given the task of looking after him - not easy when he was a ex-public school nerd. Over the years Hannah and Jude became BFFs, and even something more, then 'the thing' happened and Jude moved to Australia and blocked her on all social media.
Four years later, Hannah is dating other people, but the pain of being abandoned and ghosted by Jude has never truly left, so imagine her shock when she runs into him at a University of Sheffield seminar that she organised, as one of the guest speakers. Not only was it excruciatingly painful to run into Jude without warning, she also had to suffer him pretending he didn't know her when his former mentor introduced them.
Then Ed and Joe announce their engagement, they want Hannah to organise the wedding and for Jude to be Joe's Best Man - now there are several months where the former lovers will have to be in close proximity. Meanwhile, Hannah's ex-boyfriend, a former boyband member who now makes a living DJing weddings, isn't taking rejection well.
As is often the case with novels where 'a thing' happened in the past, the secrecy drags on far too long and becomes (for me) an irritant, then the eventual reveal is just a damp squib because it has been built up too much. Also both Jude and Hannah seemed to be labouring under the belief that they were more in love than the other and therefore they were just protecting themselves from heartbreak. I'm afraid Jane Austen holds the gold medal for this way of thinking (Persuasion) and unfortunately this was a modern day twist on a classic tale.
Available on Kindle Unlimited.
I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley.
View all my reviews








